HEPA VS MERV FILTERS: WHICH IS BETTER FOR YOUR HEAT PUMP AND HVAC SYSTEM? A TECHNICAL EXAMINATION

July 13, 2023

Introduction

Every HVAC (Heating, Ventilation, and Air Conditioning) system, including heat pumps, incorporates air filtration. It guarantees that the air in our homes and workplaces is clean, healthy, and free of potentially hazardous particles. High-Efficiency Particulate Air (HEPA) and Minimum Efficiency Reporting Value (MERV) rated filters are among the most prevalent types of filters. This article will compare HEPA and MERV filters on a technical level, analyzing their efficacy, efficiency, and compatibility with various HVAC systems.

Understanding HEPA Filters

HEPA filters are renowned for their ability to remove microscopic airborne particulates. A genuine HEPA filter must be capable of capturing 99.97% of particles with a diameter of 0.3 microns, which is considered the “most penetrating particle size” (MPPS). This capability makes HEPA filters exceptionally effective at removing pollutants such as dust mites, mold spores, pollen, animal dander, wildfire smoke-related particles, asbestos fibers, etc.

Hepa Filters

Understanding MERV Filters

Unlike HEPA, MERV is a rating system devised by the American Society of Heating, Refrigerating, and Air-Conditioning Engineers (ASHRAE) to categorize the efficiency of air filters. Ratings for MERV range from 1 to 20. Lower MERV ratings (1-4) are less effective at capturing larger particles such as carpet fibers and dust mites, whereas higher MERV ratings (13-20) can capture particles as minuscule as viruses and cigarette smoke.

Comparison: HEPA vs MERV Filters

  • Filtration Efficiency: Both HEPA and high-MERV filters can effectively filter small particles. However, true HEPA filters outperform even the highest-rated MERV filters in terms of efficiency, as they can remove 99.97% of particles at 0.3 microns.
  • Airflow and Energy Efficiency: While HEPA filters offer superior filtration, they are also denser and can restrict the airflow in your HVAC system, leading to increased energy consumption. MERV filters, especially those with ratings between 8-16, tend to offer offer a better balance between filtration efficiency and airflow restriction.
  • Compatibility: Not all HVAC systems are compatible with HEPA filters due to their density and size. The system may need to be modified or may even need a separate air filtration unit. On the other hand, MERV filters are designed to fit standard HVAC systems without any need for modification.
  • Maintenance: Both HEPA and MERV filters require regular maintenance. However, due to their superior particle capture, HEPA filters may need to be replaced more frequently, which can be more costly over time. MERV filters, particularly those in the 8-16 range, offer a balance between cost, efficiency, and maintenance.
Hepa Filters Installation

Which is Better?

The answer to whether HEPA or MERV filters are preferable for your HVAC system depends on several factors, including the specific needs of the building’s occupants, the compatibility of the HVAC system, and cost considerations.

For those with severe allergies, respiratory conditions, or who desire the utmost level of air purification, a HEPA filter may be the best option, assuming the HVAC system is capable of accommodating it.

In contrast, a high MERV filter (8-16) would be a better option for residential and commercial applications where a balance of cost, maintenance, and efficiency is desired.

In a nutshell

Consider the specific requirements of the building’s occupants, the capacity of the HVAC system, and your budget when choosing between a HEPA and MERV filter for your HVAC system. HEPA filters offer superior filtration efficacy, but they may require an HVAC system that is compatible with them and more frequent maintenance. In contrast, MERV filters offer flexibility in terms of efficacy and cost, and are generally more compatible with standard HVAC systems.

Always consult a professional HVAC technician who can evaluate your specific circumstances and guide you to the optimal filter selection. Regardless of the filter type selected, regular maintenance and timely replacement of filters are essential for the optimal operation of your HVAC system.

Frequently asked questions

HEPA and MERV rated filters have distinct functions. HEPA filters provide superior filtration, removing 99.97% of particles 0.3 microns and larger, but often significantly restrict airflow, which can strain a home's HVAC system. On a scale from 1 to 16, MERV filters provide a balance between filtration and ventilation. The higher the MERV rating, the better the filtration, but it can restrict ventilation.

For the majority of residential HVAC systems, including heat pumps, a MERV 8-16 filter provides an acceptable balance between efficient particulate filtration and system performance. Consult the manufacturer's recommendations for your HVAC system to ensure you select an appropriate filter that will not burden the system.

Although heat pumps, and other types of HVAC systems condition air, air purification is not their primary function. Adding an air purifier, particularly one with HEPA, or MERV 16 filters, can substantially improve indoor air quality by filtering smaller particles, which is beneficial for individuals with allergies, asthma, and who reside in areas with high-pollution levels. In addition, integrating air purification with heat pumps provides a comprehensive solution that effectively balances air circulation, temperature regulation, and purification. This does not, however, replace routine HVAC maintenance and filter replacement. Always consult a professional HVAC technician for tailored advice.

Yes, filters with higher resistance ratings can indeed restrict airflow more, but it's not solely due to their MERV (Minimum Efficiency Reporting Value) ratings. The resistance rating of a filter indicates how much it obstructs the airflow, which can make your HVAC system work harder and potentially reduce its efficiency and lifespan. While higher MERV-rated filters typically have higher resistance due to smaller pores designed to capture more and smaller particles, it's not always the case. Some high-quality filters with high MERV ratings are designed to balance air resistance and filtration efficiency. Therefore, it's essential to consider both MERV and resistance ratings when choosing a filter.

Whether a MERV 13 filter is suitable for a home depends heavily on the HVAC system installed and the filter's pressure drop rating. Generally speaking, MERV 8-12 filters are optimal for residential systems, harmonizing filtration and airflow. While MERV 13 filters provide superior filtration, they may increase airflow resistance, thereby decreasing system efficiency and life span. Check your system's specifications and the filter's pressure drop chart before installing a MERV 13 filter to avoid undue strain. If you have particular air quality concerns, such as severe allergies or high local pollution, a MERV 13 filter (if compatible) or an air purifier may be useful. Always consult a professional HVAC technician for personalized advice.

Pleated air filters can restrict airflow more than non-pleated filters due to the increased surface area of pleated filters, which can cause greater pressure drops. While this design effectively captures more and smaller particles, thereby improving air quality, the increased airflow resistance can cause your HVAC system to work harder. The degree of pressure drop depends on the design and composition of the filter. Regular replacement of filters in accordance with the manufacturer's recommendations can aid in preserving optimal system performance. Always consult the guidelines for your HVAC system when selecting a filter with the appropriate pressure drop rating, balancing air purity and system efficiency.

Whether a MERV 11 filter is too restrictive depends predominantly on the specifications of your HVAC system and its tolerance for pressure drop. MERV 11 filters offer a higher level of filtration efficacy, but can also increase pressure drop and airflow resistance. The majority of residential systems manage filters with MERV ratings between 8 and 12, establishing a balance between air cleanliness and system performance. Before choosing a MERV 11 filter, check your HVAC system's specifications to ensure it can accommodate the filter's pressure decrease without compromising performance. Always consult a professional HVAC technician for system-specific recommendations.

Choosing the right HVAC filter depends on several factors, including your specific HVAC system, the air quality in your area, and any specific health considerations in your household. Here are steps to guide you:

  1. Check HVAC System Specifications: Consult your HVAC system's owner's manual or contact the manufacturer to determine the correct size and type of filter. It's crucial to get a filter that fits properly.

  2. Consider Air Quality Needs: If you live in a high pollution area or have family members with allergies, asthma, or other respiratory conditions, consider a higher MERV-rated filter (within the capacity of your system) for better particle removal.

  3. Balance MERV Rating with System Performance: Higher MERV ratings offer better filtration but can also restrict airflow and make your system work harder. Most residential systems efficiently handle filters between MERV 8 and 12.

  4. Consider Pressure Drop Rating: Alongside MERV, the filter's pressure drop rating can also affect system performance. Aim for a filter with a higher MERV rating and a lower pressure drop rating within the specifications of your system.

  5. Regular Maintenance: No matter which filter you choose, regular replacement is crucial for maintaining good air quality and system efficiency. Check the filter manufacturer's recommendations for replacement intervals.

  6. Professional Advice: If in doubt, consult with an HVAC professional to get advice tailored to your specific needs and circumstances. They can assess your system and recommend the best filter options.

Remember that the best filter for your HVAC system is one that provides a balance of efficient filtration without significantly impacting system performance.

A MERV 5 filter provides fundamental filtration, capturing larger particles such as dust mites and pet dander, but is less effective at capturing smaller particles. If air quality isn't a significant concern, it is suitable for protecting your HVAC system. Nonetheless, if your system can manage it, a filter with a higher MERV rating (8–16) may provide better air quality for those with allergies, respiratory issues, or higher pollution levels. Always refer to your HVAC system's instructions and consult a professional for situation-specific advice.

The frequency of heat pump filter replacement depends on the type of filter, air quality, and system usage. In general, fiberglass filters should be replaced every 30 days, whereas pleated or high-efficiency filters can last for approximately 90 days. Deeper filters (4 inches or greater) can last between 6 and 12 months. This may occur more frequently if you have pets, allergies, or reside in an area with high levels of pollution. Always follow the recommendations of the manufacturer and replace the filter when it appears soiled. Regular filter replacements are essential for system efficiency and longevity.

While the restrictiveness of a filter is determined by its pressure drop rating, the least restrictive air filters are typically fiberglass or electronic filters. Fiberglass filters with low MERV ratings (1-4) capture large particles and provide minimal ventilation resistance, but are less effective than other filters. Electronic filters use an electric charge to attract particulates, thereby enhancing filtration without introducing a significant amount of air resistance. However, your filter selection should strike a balance between ventilation and indoor air quality. For improved air quality, it may be necessary to use filters with a higher MERV rating or an air purifier, assuming your HVAC system can accommodate them.

The MERV rating you should use is determined by your specific requirements. MERV 6-8, which removes pollen, dust mites, and carpet fibers, could be sufficient for basic filtration. If you require advanced filtration, consider MERV 9-16, which is also capable of removing automobile emissions and lead dust. MERV 13-16 can eradicate bacteria, tobacco smoke, and sneeze droplets for superior filtration. However, it's best to ensure that the pressure drop rating of your filter works with your HVAC system. 

MERV 13 filters are more effective than MERV 8 filters. While MERV 8 filters can capture particles between 3 and 10 microns in size to a certain degree (including mold spores, hair spray, and dust mites), MERV 13 filters can capture particles between 0.3 and 1 microns in size, including bacteria, tobacco smoke, and cooking oil. However, if your HVAC system is not designed for the pressure drop of your filter, it may reduce airflow.

Although filters with the highest MERV rating (MERV 16-20) are capable of removing the most and smallest particles, such as viruses, carbon dust, and marine salt, depending on their pressure drop (aka resistance), they are not typically recommended for residential HVAC systems. Highly resistant filters can restrict airflow, causing the system to work harder and potentially leading to increased energy consumption, decreased overall system performance, and even system damage if it was not designed to accommodate such filters.

Higher MERV ratings always better for your HVAC system. While they capture more and smaller particles, depending on their pressure drop ratings, they may also increase airflow resistance, which can cause the system to work harder, reduce energy efficiency, and even cause system damage if it was not designed to manage higher MERV ratings. It is essential to select a MERV rating that strikes a balance between air filtration requirements and HVAC system capabilities.

HEPA (High Efficiency Particulate Air) filters are the highest efficiency air filters available. They have an efficiency rating of 99.97% for particles of 0.3 microns, equivalent to a MERV rating between 17-20. However, they're usually not suitable for typical residential HVAC systems due to the high airflow resistance they create.

In general, more expensive HVAC filters provide superior air filtration, trapping more and smaller particles. However, the value depends on your particular requirements. If you have allergies or respiratory problems, live in a high-pollution area, or have pets, the higher price may be justified. Remember to ensure that your HVAC system can accommodate the pressure drop of the filter.

Yes, an air purifier can be added to a heat pump system to further enhance indoor air quality. Room-specific air purifiers may be used, or a whole-house air purifier may be integrated with the HVAC system. Both choices can provide superior filtration to that of standard HVAC filters. Keep in mind that professional installation of whole-house purifiers may be required.

Heat pumps do not inherently bring fresh air into the house. They recirculate indoor air, heating or cooling it as needed. For fresh air, you would need to open windows or doors, or install a separate ventilation system such as an energy recovery ventilator (ERV) or a heat recovery ventilator (HRV).

Neglecting to clean your heat pump filter can lead to a buildup of dust and other particles, restricting airflow and causing the heat pump to work harder. This can reduce energy efficacy, increase energy costs, and potentially reduce the heat pump's lifespan. In extreme circumstances, an obstructed filter can lead to the heat pump overheating, freezing, and failing.

The MERV rating you should use in your home is determined by your specific requirements and the HVAC system's capabilities. For residential use without specific air quality concerns, most people find a MERV rating between 8 and 11 should be adequate. Consider a higher MERV rating, up to 16, if your HVAC system can manage it, if there are residents with allergies or respiratory problems, or if you have pets.

Whether MERV 11 or MERV 13 is better depends on your particular requirements and whether your HVAC system can accommodate a higher MERV rating. MERV 13 filters capture more and smaller particles than MERV 11 filters, including bacteria and viruses, allowing them to offer superior air quality. However, they may restrict airflow more depending on their pressure drop rating, which can burden your HVAC system if it is not designed for such filters. Make sure to check the resistance rating of your filter. Believe it or not, some MERV 11 filters would strain your HVAC system more than some MERV 16 filters! It's all about the pressure drop!

A MERV 11 filter is not necessarily bad to your HVAC system. However, if your system was not designed to accommodate high-efficiency filters, a MERV 11 filter could restrict ventilation, resulting in increased energy consumption and potential system damage. Always examine the maximum pressure drop rating recommended for your HVAC system before installing a high-efficiency filter.

Any MERV rating that restricts airflow to a level your specific HVAC system can't handle is too restrictive. High MERV filters can capture more and smaller particles, improving indoor air quality, but they can potentially reduce airflow if their pressure drop rating is high. Restricted airflow can cause your HVAC system to work harder, increasing energy consumption and potentially damaging the system.

The replacement frequency for MERV 8 filters is dependent on factors such as the level of dust in your residence, the presence of pets, the overall air quality, the filter's initial pressure drop, and dust-holding capacity. However, it is generally recommended that they be replaced every two to three months. If you notice that the filter becomes soiled more quickly, increase the frequency of replacement. A clean filter is essential for the efficiency and longevity of your HVAC system.

A MERV 13 filter will not necessarily harm your heat pump or HVAC system. However, if your system was not designed to accommodate high-efficiency filters, the increased airflow resistance might strain your system, resulting in decreased efficiency and possible system damage. Before installing a filter with a higher MERV rating, it is always vital to verify the system's specifications (aka available pressure drop).

If your primary concern is protecting your HVAC system rather than removing smaller particles like bacteria and viruses, MERV 8 may suffice for residential use. Dust mites, mold spores, and pollen are some of the common pollutants that MERV 8 filters can trap. However, a higher MERV rating may be preferable if you have pets, have allergies or respiratory issues, or live in a high-pollution area.

Even though a MERV 13 filter can trap mold spores to some degree, it will not eliminate all mold problems in your residence. Mold spores can still enter a home through cracks, doors, and windows. Furthermore, filters do not address the necessary moisture for mildew growth. Consequently, while high MERV filters can be part of a comprehensive mold-reduction strategy, other measures, such as controlling humidity, repairing leaks, and ensuring adequate ventilation, are also essential.

Compared to foam air filters, pleated air filters typically offer superior filtration. They have a larger surface area, which enables them to capture more particles without substantially impeding airflow. Even though foam filters are washable and reusable, they typically do not provide the same level of filtration. However, they may be sufficient for systems and circumstances where high-efficiency filtration is not required.

Compared to non-pleated air filters, generally speaking, pleated air filters provide superior filtration. Their increased surface area enables them to capture more and smaller particles without substantially obstructing airflow. However, non-pleated filters may have less of an impact on airflow and may be appropriate for systems where high-efficiency filtration is not required or where maintaining optimum airflow is a priority.

Depending on the design of your HVAC system, air should either be pushed or drawn through a filter. Most residential HVAC systems are designed to pull air through the filter, trapping particles before they enter the system. Make sure to install the filter per the system's specs to ensure optimal operation and filtration efficiency.

MERV 14 filters may be compatible with your HVAC system depending on its specifications. MERV 14 filters capture very small particles, such as bacteria and tobacco smoke, but depending on their depth, and pressure drop rating, they also restrict airflow more than filters with lower MERV ratings. Before installing a MERV 14 filter, ensure that your HVAC system is designed to accommodate high-efficiency filters in order to avoid decreased efficiency or potential damage.

MERV 13 is typically superior to MERV 11 for enhancing the quality of indoor air because it can capture smaller particulate matter. However, it depends on your specific air quality requirements and the capabilities of your HVAC system as to whether this is the best option for you. Before installing a high-efficiency filter, always verify your system's highest recommended pressure drop rating.

The three most common types of residential air filters are fiberglass filters, pleated filters, and electronic filters. Fiberglass filters, the most inexpensive option, provide basic filtration. Pleated filters provide a superior level of filtration and are capable of removing smaller particulate. Electronic filters utilize an electric charge to attract and capture particulates.

Yes, there can be a considerable difference between HVAC and heat pump air filters. Their MERV ratings, which indicate the size and quantity of particulate they can capture, vary. In addition, they can be manufactured from a variety of materials, such as fiberglass, pleated paper, or fabric, and can be disposable or washable. The choice depends on specific needs such as allergen control, airflow requirements, and HVAC system specifications.

16" x 20", 20" x 25", and 16" x 20" are currently some of the most common dimensions for residential HVAC filters with a 1" thickness. However, filter size can differ significantly depending on the HVAC system in question. Make sure to check the size listed in your system's specifications, or the size of your filter return grille to ensure you purchase the correct filter size.

Whether or not higher MERV rated filters are worthwhile depends on your particular requirements. If you have allergies, respiratory issues, pets, or live in a high-pollution area, a filter with a higher MERV rating can considerably improve the air quality in your home. However, high-efficiency filters are typically more expensive and may increase energy consumption depending on their rated pressure drop.

Yes, heat pumps have filters that must be regularly replaced or cleaned. The filter protects the heat pump from dust and other contaminants that can impair its efficiency and potentially cause damage. Neglecting the filter may increase the heat pump's energy consumption and decrease its lifespan.

Yes, heat pumps have filters that must be regularly replaced or cleaned. The filter protects the heat pump from dust and other contaminants that can impair its efficiency and potentially cause damage. Neglecting the filter may increase the heat pump's energy consumption and decrease its lifespan.

The best way to clean heat pump filters depends on the type of filter. When disposable filters become soiled, they should be replaced, typically every one to three months. If your heat pump has a washable filter, remove it, clean it with a mild detergent and tepid water, rinse it thoroughly, and allow it to dry thoroughly before reinstalling it. Make sure to comply with the filter's manufacturer's guidelines.

The lifespan of an air filter is dependent on its type and your particular conditions. Standard disposable fiberglass filters typically last 1-3 months, whereas pleated filters higher depth and dust holding capacity can last 3-6 months. Some high-efficiency filters have a one-year lifespan. Although washable filters can last for several years, they should still be cleaned every month or so. The lifespan of a filter can be affected by factors such as the level of dust in a home, the presence of pets, and the overall air quality.

{{ reviewsOverall }} / 10 Users (0 votes)
PFE1 Efficiency (0.3-1 μm)0
PFE2 (1-3 μm)0
Permeability / Pressure Drop0
What people say... Login to rate
Order by:

Be the first to leave a review.

Verified

Show more
{{ pageNumber+1 }}